Company goes silent after pulling ads from 'All-American Muslim'

Should Lowe's need a crowbar to pull its head out of the sand, it can find one in its own aisles. On Saturday, the home-improvement company posted a note to Facebook explaining its decision to capitulate to an email campaign by the Florida Family Association and pull its ads from the TLC reality show All-American Muslim. As of this writing, the post has drawn more than 22,000 comments, a significant portion of which are racist and contain anti-Muslim/anti-Islamic hate speech. (Scroll down to see some of them.) So, why isn't Lowe's moderating its Facebook wall?
"If Lowe's was concerned about spreading hate speech, you would think that they would filter and delete the worst [comments]," says Ibrahim Hooper, communications director for the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR). "It's hard to tell if leaving them up is intentional or not." CAIR sent Lowe's CEO Robert Niblock a letter on Monday requesting a meeting to discuss the pulling of ads from the TLC show but has received no response so far. Late Tuesday, CAIR plans to release a statement condemning Lowe's for allowing the bigoted speech to remain on its Facebook wall.
Josh Bernoff, senior vp of idea development at Forrester Research and co-author of Groundswell and Empowered, says Lowe's has made several strategic errors throughout this ordeal. First was the decision to pull the ads. Now, he says, it's compounding the problem by responding only to press questions and remaining mute in social media. Its most recent tweet, from Saturday, directs people to the Facebook post. Since then, the discussion has only gotten more heated as national news media have picked up the original story. "Hoping this will die down if you don't participate never works," says Bernoff. "It doesn't tamp down anything." He adds: "The first thing they need to do is decide what they believe. It's not clear at this point." After that, he says, they need to put that message out in every online medium possible.
In its Facebook post, Lowe's writes, "We strongly support and respect the right of our customers, the community at large, and our employees to have different views." Yet bigotry isn't a "different view" that does much good for a brand. Lowe's must think that if it stays above the fray, it can't be held accountable. But the ballooning number of racist comments on its Facebook wall is an accounting all its own.
On Tuesday, hip-hop mogul Russell Simmons said he had bought up all remaining ad space on All-American Muslim to protest Lowe's decision. On Sunday, Sen. Ted Lieu (D-Calif.) told the Associated Press that he was considering calling for a boycott against Lowe's and weighing possible legislative action. It's not inconceivable that a presidential candidate might weigh in. The less Lowe's says, the more others do the talking for them.
Not everyone is against Lowe's. "Thank You!!! On may [sic] way to Lowe's to do some CHRISTmas shopping!" reads one Facebook comment. "Y'all got any tools down there at Lowe's I can use to seal my house up night and tight-like?" reads another. "I'd be fixin' to cut me a hickory switch if a minority ever got in there!" Seems Lowe's is attracting another breed of shopper this week. It remains to be seen whether those who aren't tolerant of Muslims buy more home-improvement supplies than those who are.
Lowe's did not respond to email and phone requests seeking comment.



SOURCE
Update: Jon Stewart talked about this story on The Daily Show last night
Update: Looks like Lowe's removed the entire thread (including their announcement) from their Facebook page
Update: Lowe's explanation for deleting the thread

It seems to me that the only comments they're not censoring are the ones supporting Lowe's and its decision.

Should Lowe's need a crowbar to pull its head out of the sand, it can find one in its own aisles. On Saturday, the home-improvement company posted a note to Facebook explaining its decision to capitulate to an email campaign by the Florida Family Association and pull its ads from the TLC reality show All-American Muslim. As of this writing, the post has drawn more than 22,000 comments, a significant portion of which are racist and contain anti-Muslim/anti-Islamic hate speech. (Scroll down to see some of them.) So, why isn't Lowe's moderating its Facebook wall?
"If Lowe's was concerned about spreading hate speech, you would think that they would filter and delete the worst [comments]," says Ibrahim Hooper, communications director for the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR). "It's hard to tell if leaving them up is intentional or not." CAIR sent Lowe's CEO Robert Niblock a letter on Monday requesting a meeting to discuss the pulling of ads from the TLC show but has received no response so far. Late Tuesday, CAIR plans to release a statement condemning Lowe's for allowing the bigoted speech to remain on its Facebook wall.
Josh Bernoff, senior vp of idea development at Forrester Research and co-author of Groundswell and Empowered, says Lowe's has made several strategic errors throughout this ordeal. First was the decision to pull the ads. Now, he says, it's compounding the problem by responding only to press questions and remaining mute in social media. Its most recent tweet, from Saturday, directs people to the Facebook post. Since then, the discussion has only gotten more heated as national news media have picked up the original story. "Hoping this will die down if you don't participate never works," says Bernoff. "It doesn't tamp down anything." He adds: "The first thing they need to do is decide what they believe. It's not clear at this point." After that, he says, they need to put that message out in every online medium possible.
In its Facebook post, Lowe's writes, "We strongly support and respect the right of our customers, the community at large, and our employees to have different views." Yet bigotry isn't a "different view" that does much good for a brand. Lowe's must think that if it stays above the fray, it can't be held accountable. But the ballooning number of racist comments on its Facebook wall is an accounting all its own.
On Tuesday, hip-hop mogul Russell Simmons said he had bought up all remaining ad space on All-American Muslim to protest Lowe's decision. On Sunday, Sen. Ted Lieu (D-Calif.) told the Associated Press that he was considering calling for a boycott against Lowe's and weighing possible legislative action. It's not inconceivable that a presidential candidate might weigh in. The less Lowe's says, the more others do the talking for them.
Not everyone is against Lowe's. "Thank You!!! On may [sic] way to Lowe's to do some CHRISTmas shopping!" reads one Facebook comment. "Y'all got any tools down there at Lowe's I can use to seal my house up night and tight-like?" reads another. "I'd be fixin' to cut me a hickory switch if a minority ever got in there!" Seems Lowe's is attracting another breed of shopper this week. It remains to be seen whether those who aren't tolerant of Muslims buy more home-improvement supplies than those who are.
Lowe's did not respond to email and phone requests seeking comment.



SOURCE
Update: Jon Stewart talked about this story on The Daily Show last night
Update: Looks like Lowe's removed the entire thread (including their announcement) from their Facebook page
Update: Lowe's explanation for deleting the thread

It seems to me that the only comments they're not censoring are the ones supporting Lowe's and its decision.
You get racist fleas.
I don't understand the hate -it actually puzzles me and deeply disturbs me. Because despite what "Allotta" says, it's ALL born out of ignorance - just enough information to be dangerous. But beyond that, it's taking that little bit of information and running with it, not being able to separate the extremism of a few from the every day lives of many.
Nope. `Cause no one gives a shit, and even if they did, their voice would be drowned out by the howling, willfully ignorant masses that make up the majority of the voting block of South Carolina.
These fools, they deserve it. Good for the people on there trying to speak sense, though I'm not sure what good it will do.
I just tried to google a list of the companies who pulled their ads and I found this article. Uhmmmm. What?
As for those comments--I kind of wish I believed in hell so those people could go there. Anyway, I will wish them to go there posthaste, metaphorically.
Also lol at Redneckistan.
I mentioned this to my (white, male) coworker and he had sense enough to realize that "being white in America" summed up about 98% of television on air right now. He literally said, "that's already on TV, right?"
I already thought highly of him, but my opinion of him got exponentially higher after that admission.
/just wanted to share this macro
Not to mention, I am tired of calling out some of my friends for their ~oh so hilarious~ jokes and just having my comments deleted. Fuck you, jerks.
/rant
Edited at 2011-12-14 05:43 pm (UTC)