McDonnell signs state rape bill.
Bob McDonnell, Virginia Governor, Signs Mandatory Ultrasound Bill Into Law
Source: HuffPo![]()
WASHINGTON -- Va. Gov. Bob McDonnell signed a controversial mandatory ultrasound bill into law Wednesday afternoon, making Virginia the seventh state to require women to have an ultrasound procedure before they can legally have an abortion.
A previous version of the bill would have forced women to undergo an invasive, likely painful transvaginal ultrasound procedure if she was too early into the pregnancy for a more typical transabdominal one to detect fetal age. After that bill sparked widespread protests, McDonnell and House Republicans worked together to write a new bill that would allow women to opt out of the more invasive procedure in favor of an external one.
Democrats are still not pleased with the compromise. Critics of the bill say that it's medically unnecessary and constitutes an egregious government overreach into personal medical decisions that women should make with their doctors.
The bill, which some Democrats are comparing to state-sponsored rape, has sparked several protests at Virginia's state Capitol in Richmond.
"We have taken out the state-required rape from the bill, but the way it is now is still an assault because it's an unwanted touching," state Sen. Janet Howell (D) told HuffPost in an interview, "and the woman is being coerced to have that happen in order to exercise her constitutional right to an abortion."
Americans United for Life, an anti-abortion group that wrote a model ultrasound bill on which Virginia Republicans and lawmakers from several other states have based theirs, called Virginia's new law the "gold standard of medical care" on Wednesday.
"Abortion advocates engaged in a vicious campaign of misinformation against a proposal that would require a life-saving ultrasound test before giving women an abortion-inducing drug or an abortion procedure," AUL CEO Dr. Charmaine Yoest said in a statement on Wednesday. "We know that women with ectopic pregnancies have died when given life-ending drugs, which makes it particularly egregious that abortion advocates fought to prevent women from having all the medical information they need for informed consent. Ultrasounds are the gold standard of medical care, and women deserve to have such testing."
OP ETA:
The Rachel Maddow Show had a great segment on this last night explaining how the "new" bill isn't much different at all. It leaves the possibility of mandatory and medically unnecessary vaginal probing (i.e. legislated rape) quite open and perhaps even probable. Maddow explains how the amended bill still requires proof of gestational age. Thus although it removes the 'mandate' for the Vaginal Probe, it still does mandate the "bell jelly" (external) ultrasound of AND that ultrasound can't determine the gestational age. So the the woman has to be "offered" the internal vaginal probe ultrasound. What happens if she says NO? The law DOES NOT clarify. Thus leaving it open for interpretation by whatever fuckhead local doctor, or official. I can't help but believe that this law will ultimately be found unconstitutional if only for the vague language.
This has not been a good year for my blood pressure.
A previous version of the bill would have forced women to undergo an invasive, likely painful transvaginal ultrasound procedure if she was too early into the pregnancy for a more typical transabdominal one to detect fetal age. After that bill sparked widespread protests, McDonnell and House Republicans worked together to write a new bill that would allow women to opt out of the more invasive procedure in favor of an external one.
Not saying the bill is no longer bullshit, I just feel like since external ultrasounds are now an option to call it a 'rape bill' is just diluting the word.
...I hate my state right now.
... see, now, the funny thing with that is that one excuse given to me was that it was mandatory to check on the age of the fetus prior to the procedure, to ensure it wasn't three months old, thus making it a late term abortion.
I ain't a biologist or a doctor with fancy booklearnins, but I'm pretty sure if it's too early to tell the age with a standard procedure, one would be pretty safe to bet that the fetus is way less than three months old, now wouldn't it?
So... the need for sonograms does not seem to make sense to me in order for a woman to have an abortion. Pregnancy can be confirmed from a simple blood or urine test, and gestational size from measuring a women's uterus size.
I wrote a pretty long and strongly-worded (though not profane) letter -- about the eight billionth I've sent to some gov't official or another this season, it feels like.
Furthermore, if a woman has saved up the money and traveled a presumably long distance to get an abortion - that means that she wants an abortion. Medically unnecessary ultrasounds will do nothing but either; piss her off, or make her feel violated and uncomfortable.
"We know that women with ectopic pregnancies have died when given life-ending drugs
Citation needed. Ectopic pregnancies are almost always a threat to the woman's life - and you either don't see that, or don't care. You're doing a good job of proving that you hate women, though, so keep it up! :D
I thought assisted suicide was illegal?
Also, what do you expect if you give someone life-ending drugs? Of course they'll die!
seriously just arggg
Can someone do this to him? I just...why does my state fail so much??
These lawmakers don't give a shit about abortions or babies or women. They want us to get out of the public sphere altogether and the most time-tested way they can think of is to keep us occupied with children at all costs. They are anti-women, full stop.
I can't even anymore.
Oh, and "Bob's For Jobs!" How's that coming along? (I mean, setting aside our reliance and benefitting from horrible, horrible federal gummint jobs, which are bad in GOP World until they keep your unemployment rate relatively low and then they're not.)
Sorry, got on a bit of rant there...