ONTD Political

Subject: George Lucas v Marin County Brats: Grady Ranch Low-Income Housing

1:00 pm - 05/14/2012
George Lucas Studio Expansion Shut Down: Star Wars Creator Earmarks Grady Ranch for Low-Income Housing Development

George Lucas, who created and then besmirched the Star Wars saga, has trolled his tony Marin County neighbors in a masterful fashion:

George Lucas has planned a Lucasfilm studio expansion on Grady Ranch, a property he owns in the picturesque Lucas Valley (not named for him, by the way). However, his neighbors (such as they are: houses in that area are not really visible to each other) cock-blocked his moves at every turn.

Despite meticulous planning and environmental impact studies, it became clear that, if George Lucas' plan ever came to fruition (which it probably wouldn't), his studio would be surrounded by constantly hostile neighbors, who clearly hate Jawas.

George Lucas then decided to take the troll road: leveraging the very NIMBYism that scuppered his original plan. George Lucas has partnered with the Marin Community Foundation to develop the Grady Ranch property into a low-income housing development.

Marin County is a pretty affluent area overall, and Lucas Valley is affluent by Marin standards. Marin County brats do not like "affordable housing". Of course, Tupac Shakur is a product of affordable housing in Marin City, so perhaps they could reconsider.

This paragraph in the Chron made me laugh:

Several Lucas Valley Estates homeowners had, in fact, said that they considered the historic Lucas-owned farmland their back yards. They claimed the proposed 263,701-square-foot digital technology production complex was too large, would displace too much dirt, would change the course of a creek going through the area, create too much traffic and hadn't been studied enough.

Source: sfgate.com

The property is not the neighbors' back yards. It's Lucas' back yard. I should know, having been chased off the property on more than one occasion as a teenager. It's Lucas' own fault for having such climbing-friendly rocks on his property, so visible from Lucas Valley Road.

I don't really see this plan coming to fruition, given Lucas' neighbors' antipathy towards Jawas and Tusken Raiders, never mind real-life strangers. Still, these types of homeowners, in my opinion, richly deserve to get trolled.

Actually, Lucas Valley Road is not the ideal location for affordable housing, i.e. for people who have to work for a living: it's kind of a pain in the ass to get anywhere from Grady Ranch... and even then, you must deal with commuter traffic on 101. Not for nothing, but that traffic is the way it is because of NIMBYism as well: Marin could have had BART.

A few of the readers who tweeted this item went with "Use the troll, Luke", and I'm remiss for not thinking of it first.

Sauce
Additional Flavor

The Muffy's and Tad's of Marin should have let the movie studio get built. /kanyeshrug Hopefully something can be done to stick em in the eye in some way, shape, or form. PS: George Lucas and/or 'Use the troll, Luke' tag!?
redstar826 14th-May-2012 09:59 pm (UTC)
I'm not saying that the neighbors concerns were justified in this case, but I think there are times when people really do have good reason to be concerned about nearby developments, even if they don't own the property being developed.

For instance, we have a church down the street from us that expanded their building a few years ago and became just too damned big for the neighborhood. Yeah, it's their property, but when their building grew out to the point where they didn't have enough space on their property for adequate parking, it became everyone else's problem too. Our residential streets really weren't set up for heavy flows of traffic and large numbers of people parking on the streets (they are pretty narrow).

erunamiryene 14th-May-2012 10:07 pm (UTC)
Fair point. Although, that's incredibly poor property planning on their part, not ensuring there was enough room for parking.

IDK, that quote about "well, it's my backyard!" just really rubbed me the wrong way, because a bunch of upper-class folks came in where I live and subdivision'd it up next to long-established farms and ranches, and then started going on the news and writing to newspapers complaining about the smells and the noise and basically demanding that the farmers and ranchers move because they 'didn't like living by farms and ranches', complete with the same nonsense "BUT THAT'S MYYYYYYY BACKYARD" line. It's when it's entitled people whining that it irks me.
kyra_neko_rei 14th-May-2012 10:20 pm (UTC)
Ugh. If it was there when you moved in, how much brainpower does it NOT TAKE to figure out that if a ranch smells like X and sounds like Y on the day you tour the property, it's gonna smell like X and sound like Y in the future, too.

It's like getting pulled over for running a red light and whining, "But it was yellow when I was coming up to it! How was I supposed to know it would turn red?"
redstar826 14th-May-2012 11:18 pm (UTC)
It's when it's entitled people whining that it irks me.

I totally get that :)

the_gabih 15th-May-2012 03:24 pm (UTC)
Hah, my grandparents' commune has the same problem. They live in the south of France in a very rural area, and they have no issue with the dairy farms and such, but some of the more recent emigres have been kicking up a huge fuss about the smell on the way into the village (which isn't great, granted, but 1. they go everywhere by car, they can just turn the air con off for a few minutes and 2. like you said, it's been there since before I was born, and well before they showed up).

They also reject the traditional farmhouses in favour of building new, ugly-as-fuck ones because they're easier to wire up for electricity and plumbing and so on, but that's another matter.
mirhanda 15th-May-2012 06:08 pm (UTC)
Yeah, I agree. It sounds like he'd be disturbing a creek which can seriously impact wildlife. I'm not sure the neighbors were wrong. I think most of us wouldn't want a huge production facility in our backyards anyway, think of all the extra traffic and such.
This page was loaded May 22nd 2013, 11:01 pm GMT.