ONTD Political

PSYCHOdelic Rorschach ook

Update: Charges dropped against honor student jailed for truancy

8:47 pm - 05/31/2012


The 17-year-old Willis High School honor student whose 24-hour stay in jail for excessive truancy drew national attention had the charge rescinded Wednesday, records show.

Precinct 1 Justice of the Peace Lanny Moriarty, at the Montgomery County District Attorney's request, signed an order that vacates the contempt of court conviction that sent Diane Tran to jail last week.

The decision clears the way for the issue to be expunged from her record.

The action was taken, in part, after Moriarty looked at the extenuating circumstances that had resulted in Tran missing school and because her court summons had failed to notify her of her right to an attorney or to have one appointed for her, officials said.

Moriarty had counseled Tran the first time she was summoned to his court for excessive truancy April 25. He explained the importance of going to class and ordered her to start attending regularly.

But on May 23 Tran was brought back for failing to attend an additional four days as well as portions of another four days.

During her court appearance, however, Tran never revealed any personal struggles to the court.

Tran, a junior described by friends as "quiet and shy," could not be reached for comment. But her attorney, Brian Wice, said Tran was under an incredible amount of pressure from working two jobs and was unsure what to tell the court.

"She is not someone unwilling to come to class because she's attending a rock concert," Wice said. "She's an incredible gal who is working and studying sometimes 24 hours a day and contributing to her siblings' support more than a teenager should have a right to do."

Case draws attention

Her case created a national uproar after various media reports suggested she had legitimate reasons for being too exhausted to attend her classes. In an interview on KHOU (Channel 11, Houston, Texas), Tran cried about her parents divorcing and leaving her to fend for herself. She talked of working two jobs and helping support two siblings.

She was living three or four days a week with the owner of a wedding venue, The Vineyards of Waverly Manor, the owner's granddaughter, Starla Hill said.

"The rest of the time she is staying at her own apartment where her father visits her when he's not working in Houston," Hill said.

To support herself, Tran helps cater wedding events on weekends and works at a dry cleaners daily after school until it closes at night, Hill said.

Some of the money she earns is also being used to assist a younger sister living with another Houston relative and her brother who is attending Texas A&M University, Hill added. When Tran's jobs are done, she must also complete hours of homework for the heavy course-load she's taking.

"She's not failing any classes and getting more As than Bs," said Hill, who felt locking her up in jail was wrong. "She's doing the best she can."

Fund drive for Tran

Willis ISD spokeswoman Erin Kleinecke said mandatory attendance laws require schools to report any child who has repeated absences and penalties issued are at the court's discretion.

Kleinecke said she could not discuss the student's grades or attendance records.

Wice praised Moriarty and Assistant District Attorney Phil Grant for helping to clear Tran's record. "We're gratified they decided to do this in the interest of true justice. Anybody involved now realizes it's the right thing to do," said Wice, who is working pro bono.

He now plans to have the record expunged so it will not impact any efforts to attend college or obtain student loans.

An Internet fund drive (HelpDianeTran.com) run by the Louisiana Children's Education Alliance has reported raising $100,000 from 49 states and 18 countries to help support her. Wice said she has no control over the fund but has undisclosed plans in the future to "earmark some of it for a greater need than her own."

Source: http://www.chron.com/default/article/Charges-dropped-against-honor-student-jailed-for-3596613.php
idreamofdraco 1st-Jun-2012 03:44 am (UTC)
I'm a little confused by the last line. Is it saying that Wice plans to earmark some of the money, or is it just reporting that Wice said Tran plans to earmark some of the money?
ameliorate 1st-Jun-2012 05:24 am (UTC)
Yes, that last sentence has me confused. I keep reading it and feeling like an idiot because I can not figure out what it means. I am just hoping they mean that Tran and her siblings are going to be able to get what they need.
robintheshrew 1st-Jun-2012 03:54 am (UTC)
But what about the parents? They should be punished, they abandoned her! This isn't her responsibility!
xdawnfirex 1st-Jun-2012 04:10 am (UTC)
I think I gotta agree with this one. Her parents really ought to be held accountable for this.
homasse 1st-Jun-2012 04:15 am (UTC)
GOOD. This poor kid needs help, not jail. I hope that judge feels like an ass.
starbonds 1st-Jun-2012 05:09 am (UTC)
Why hasn't CPS been called yet for the two parents who abandoned their two underage daughters?
gelaecter 1st-Jun-2012 05:32 am (UTC)
...I'm confused. Why on earth would a 17 year old be sent to JAIL for missing school? That ridiculous, especially with her circumstaces
ook 1st-Jun-2012 06:24 am (UTC)
Because the judge is a douchebag who has taken a hard line against truancy.

Also, while in court, Tran kept quiet about her circumstances, so evidently the judge wasn't totally aware of all that was going on with her (which is why he later dropped the charges). I'm sure the public outcry against this also influenced the judge's decision to drop charges.
whatyouthinkiam 3rd-Jun-2012 05:56 am (UTC)
This is something that has never made any fucking sense to me, though I've seen similar things before. I knew this guy in high school. He decided to drop out, and since he was older than 16, this was legally his right. However, when he hesistated and wanted to come back (about a week later), he found out he would've been suspended for skipping class.

This is dumb as fuck. If you seriously want kids to finish school, punishing them for doing so is inconsistent.
iamduvet 1st-Jun-2012 06:17 am (UTC)
I would like to know where are the parents in all this?!

But I am glad she got her record cleaned.
moonshaz 1st-Jun-2012 08:11 am (UTC)
Like a lot of others here, I would also like to know wtf is up with this girl's parents. Not only is the whole situation completely bizarre, but the article's failing to say one word about them and why things are this way is even more bizarre, afaic.
korppi_ravn 1st-Jun-2012 12:05 pm (UTC)
Wait wat

You can be jailed for skipping school in the US? A few years back, I missed almost two months put together (around 50 days) of school due to issues I didn't myself understand. The teachers just used my grades from the year before as my graduation grades for applying for higher education. And I was far from a honor student, more like an under-achiever.
magli 1st-Jun-2012 04:16 pm (UTC)
I was shocked about that too. Here you can risk not getting your diploma if you miss too many classes, but it's a case between you and the school system. The justice system has nothing to do with it.
zemi_chan 1st-Jun-2012 12:31 pm (UTC)
Thank goodness this was finally straightened out.

I had to drop out of school recently because I was missing too much, due to chronic health issues. I can't imagine being thrown in jail for something that is totally out of my hands. I hope Tran gets the assistance that she needs and MORE than deserves.

Edited at 2012-06-01 12:33 pm (UTC)
ceasetoknow 1st-Jun-2012 04:27 pm (UTC)
IKR. The year I dropped out I think I missed about 2 months one term and then 2 months the term after, before I finally quit. Being chased up by my school checking I was really sick would not have help at all, especially since my doc was less than supportive at the time.
magli 1st-Jun-2012 02:05 pm (UTC)
I have not paid attention to this at all and I'm not American, so forgive me if I'm asking an obvious question: Is truancy something you can get jailed for in Texas? Can you also get jailed for not showing up at work?
carmy_w 1st-Jun-2012 03:05 pm (UTC)
If you are in high school, yes, you can be put in juvenile detention for excessive truancy.

The burden isn't entirely on the children; the parent's are also listed as defendants (at least they are here in Kansas), since they are responsible for the child.
mandrill 1st-Jun-2012 03:37 pm (UTC)
You can get fired for not showing up at work.
cruel_disorder 1st-Jun-2012 02:19 pm (UTC)
My friend's parents returned to their native country when he was 17, leaving him to take care of a huge house for the rest of his senior year before he moved into residence for university. They financially supported him and definitely came back to visit twice or thrice that school year but it pretty much permanently damaged their relationship and to this day (6 years later) he still cannot stand living with them. He's now working full-time (enough to support himself, rent a condo, etc.) and the only way he can amicably communicate with them is if he sees them once a year. :\
mrasaki 1st-Jun-2012 06:20 pm (UTC)
yes, THANK YOU. Some of the cultural assumptions happening in this post is starting to piss me off.
mrasaki 1st-Jun-2012 06:19 pm (UTC)
I don't blame her for not wanting to tell the judge about her extenuating circumstances -- maybe it varies from state to state but I'm pretty sure working 40+ hours a week for someone under 18 is illegal, and on top of that I'm sure some of that income is under the table.

I personally know other people (Vietnamese, even), whose parents moved away and left them to fend for themselves. Most were adults by then, albeit in full-time college; another was 17 and wanted to stay behind to finish high school with his friends, so he was left with family friends. We don't know exactly what went on here exactly, nor the reasons behind the decisions made, and it does NOT mean she was automatically left without familial support of any kind.

And it's not unusual, esp in immigrant/Asian families, for the entire family to pitch in to support other family members -- so the comments here re: OMG THE OLDER BROTHER is REALLY rubbing me the wrong way. Also, we /don't/ know what his own level of contribution is, nor how much financial support is going in other directions or if her own parents weren't sending her money or if THEY even had the money to send, so let's not assume, shall we?

Edited at 2012-06-01 06:25 pm (UTC)
cozmic_oceanz 1st-Jun-2012 06:47 pm (UTC)
This!
lickbrains 1st-Jun-2012 07:25 pm (UTC)
Wice praised Moriarty and Assistant District Attorney Phil Grant for helping to clear Tran's record.
Giving the guy who jailed her to begin with a little too much credit imo. He gave her a lot more stress than she already had. It's good that she got through this. I just hope she's still able to support herself.

Edited at 2012-06-01 08:07 pm (UTC)
poisoncity 2nd-Jun-2012 03:52 am (UTC)
This whole situation was so messed up. I'm really glad it got sorted out.

Oddly, I missed - like - my entire freshman/sophomore years. I probably went once a week. I never actually officially dropped out, in the end. They finally figured out I just wasn't gonna go back and left me be. :/
This page was loaded May 22nd 2013, 6:31 am GMT.