ONTD Political

No evidence of mermaids, says US government.

5:11 pm - 07/03/2012
There is no evidence that mermaids exist, a US government scientific agency has said.

The National Ocean Service made the unusual declaration in response to public inquiries following a TV show on the mythical creatures.

It is thought some viewers may have mistaken the programme for a documentary.

"No evidence of aquatic humanoids has ever been found," the service wrote in an online post.

The National Ocean Service posted an article last week on its educational website, Ocean Facts.

Images and tales of mermaids - half-human, half-fish - appear in mythology and art from across the world and through history, from Homer's Odyssey to the oral lore of the Australian aboriginals, the service wrote.

The article was written from publicly available sources because "we don't have a mermaid science programme", National Ocean Service spokeswoman Carol Kavanagh told the BBC.

She said that at least two people had written to the agency asking about the creatures.

The inquiries followed May's broadcast of Mermaids: The Body Found, on the Discovery Channel's Animal Planet network.

The programme was a work of fiction but its wink-and-nod format apparently led some viewers to believe it was a science education show, the Discovery Channel has acknowledged.

Source: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-18692830

OP: Hmm...people taking a fictional TV programme as fact? Not as crazy as it may seem, in the UK they used to put shows on on April 1st that presented themselves as factual, one about spaghetti growing on trees for example.

This one freaked people out and has become a cult classic and is well worth a look on YouTube for its spookiness:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternative_3
soundczech 3rd-Jul-2012 05:16 pm (UTC)
if it's not clearly denoted as fiction i can kind of understand how some people might get confused about this kind of thing, especially given it's airing on a network that generally deals in fact. especially because this is an ocean creature we're talking about, and the ocean is full of fucked up things that people thought were myths before they were proved to be real, like the colossal squid. who the fuck knows what else is down there. the ocean is crazy.

http://www.australiangeographic.com.au/journal/undiscovered-monsters-lurk-in-ocean-depths-says-expert.htm
maladaptive 3rd-Jul-2012 05:35 pm (UTC)
if it's not clearly denoted as fiction i can kind of understand how some people might get confused about this kind of thing, especially given it's airing on a network that generally deals in fact.

I saw the show because I love those fictional "what-if" documentaries (don't judge me) and it was seriously annoying because it talked about government cover ups a lot. Like "our plucky team of scientists found out that some government agency was hiding information about a mermaid sighting on a beach, so we went and hunted that info down and here it is!"

The mermaids were poorly CGed in the way of those low-budget documentaries, but I can see how people might have fallen for it (we're talking about a country where 30%+ believe in Bigfoot and 50%+ believe in ghosts, so believing the tv show about mermaids isn't that farfetched). I started in the middle of the program and don't remember seeing any "this is a work of fiction" disclaimers. They may have been there before commercial breaks and I just tuned them out, but I don't remember them.
jettakd 3rd-Jul-2012 05:18 pm (UTC)
Ooooh anybody remember Ghostwatch in the UK and all the people that freaked out? I finally saw it the other week and I can definitely see why it did, since it was played straight. Stuff like that, where people end up taking it seriously, happens A LOT.

eta: thanks for the headsup on Alt3 btw, will be checking that out :D

Edited at 2012-07-03 05:19 pm (UTC)
atomic_joe2 3rd-Jul-2012 05:37 pm (UTC)
Ghostwatch! I still can't watch some of that stuff on YT. Still spooks me out. That caused kids to have treatment for post traumatic stress and I think a guy committed suicide too.
jettakd 3rd-Jul-2012 05:38 pm (UTC)
Holy crap I had no idea it caused that much trauma D: I mean it made me not sleep the night I got it, but I did know it was fake going in. That's so horrible :(
jettakd 3rd-Jul-2012 05:45 pm (UTC)
Wow, I honestly had no idea that a tv show could cause that kind of trauma :(
alryssa 3rd-Jul-2012 08:58 pm (UTC)
God, I remember watching that when it first aired! I had no idea about the trauma it caused in others though :/
mirhanda 3rd-Jul-2012 05:36 pm (UTC)
I saw the very beginning of that stupid show and it was definitely presented as a factual show, however the subject matter was so stupid I got up and googled the title and found out it was a "mocumentary" so I switched it off. I wouldn't blame someone for taking it as read though, especially a person who is naive already. And it was presented on Animal Planet which (used to) actually deal in factual documentaries about animals. It's mostly crap now though.
crossfire 3rd-Jul-2012 06:37 pm (UTC)
Totes could be cross-posted to ontd_science :D
simplefaith08 3rd-Jul-2012 06:45 pm (UTC)
To be fair, I saw that show with my friends and for most of it we were like "Not sure if srs |:" (as in, we couldn't tell if it was a work of fiction done in a documentary style or people trying to tout their lack of proof as fact).
radges 4th-Jul-2012 04:09 am (UTC)
My mom was watching this and I could tell it was fake since the "actual video footage" had the same cgi as their made up footage of all the other mermaids underwater...
thelastpen 3rd-Jul-2012 07:53 pm (UTC)
Animal Planet has a lot of "fake is real" shows lately. IMO, they're badly done mockumentaries in the vein of The Blair Witch Project. "Lost Tapes" for example. It's gotten to the point that I don't even waste my time watching the channel and I used to really love their shows. Back when they were actual fact and not idiotic horror shows. If I want to watch horror, I'll go watch something like The Horror Channel. If it was a legit show on crypids done in a "present the stories and claims as they are without bias", maybe it'd be interesting. Too bad they had to go stupid flair instead.

As for fiction being mistaken as real and causing panic, don't forget about the Mercury Theater On The Air's production of Orson Welles's War of the Worlds back in 1938. Yes, it was regularly announced that it was fiction, but people still freaked out. And then there's the 1949 Spanish reproduction that caused panic and riot in Quito, Ecuador that left six dead - including the girlfriend and nephew of one of the men responsible for the reproduction.
moonshaz 3rd-Jul-2012 09:21 pm (UTC)
About the only things I watch on AP are the pet-oriented things like Dogs 101, Cats 101, It's Me or the Dog, My Cat from Hell, etc. THAT stuff is fun and often actually informative. And oh, yeah, Tanked is usually good for a few laughs, plus I love the (unfortunately fleeting) shots of the exotic fish. But almost everything else on that channel is complete B.S.

I immediately thought of the Mercury Theater incident when I read this story, but hadn't heard about the Quito riot, or the Ghostwatch thing. I guess this kind of thing (people confusing fact with fiction) must happen a lot more often than I realized.
mirhanda 3rd-Jul-2012 10:40 pm (UTC)
I know! It's so horrible now what A.P. has become. The only decent show left is River Monsters, IMO. At least they have an actual biologist on that show.
liyosa 4th-Jul-2012 08:30 pm (UTC)
My parents disconnected from the more expensive cable a long while back because we weren't watching 90% of the extra channels. I was heartbroken because animal planet used to be my favorite channel, especially with all the documentaries about wildlife with british voiceovers.

I'm so sad to hear this is what it's become D: D: D:. What a tragedy.
16_bit_goddess 3rd-Jul-2012 08:19 pm (UTC)
psh. they WOULD say that.
furrygreen 3rd-Jul-2012 09:12 pm (UTC)
Good to know. I mean, what with the full scale invasions from hurricanes each year and killer tsunami's (really, Ocean? The earth shifts a little and you think that's justification for an overblown bitch-slap?), I think having a possible mermaid/man invasion would've just been more that most people can handle. The ocean is already planning on repo'ing several feet of coastal land. This would've just added insult to injury. (BTW, when are we going to declare the 'War on Ocean'? Have you see the Ocean(s) lately? It's looking rather shifty. I don't trust it. What are you hiding under miles of water? It can't be good.)

Hmm...people taking a fictional TV programme as fact?

I think some people do. I heard "rumors" that Chinese people turn their aborted fetuses into dumplings and that it's a "delicacy". I thought, WTF would believe that shit? And then I remember there's an obscure (for the US, at least) Chinese horror movie about a Chinese woman who made dumplings from fetuses to preserve her clients youthful looks and I thought: OMG >_> Really?
liyosa 4th-Jul-2012 08:39 pm (UTC)
Yeahhhh my housemates believe that. It makes no sense, because that's their motherland, but they's the type who believe that China needs a serious dose of God and Christianity -_______-.

Then again, they also believed Chinese were making fake eggs with gelatin and sodium acetate, and that they were importing them to Chinese sellers in Ireland.

They're nice people and all, but damn they can be led to believe anything. And they're going to become doctors too...
furrygreen 4th-Jul-2012 08:59 pm (UTC)
I always thinking that believing baby-eating in any form has always been a staple of whatever other group (other than your own) since the dawn of time. Jews were often thought of eating babies. Witches were accused of stealing men's penis' and putting them in a nest in a tree.

It's ridiculous that people still believe that to this day.

The Chinese horror movie wasn't even all that good. You should ask your friends if they think Chinese people believe some psycho killer jumps into teenagers dreams to kill them all the time over here. XD
mypetconcubine 3rd-Jul-2012 09:46 pm (UTC)
They would say that :P
wumbawoman 3rd-Jul-2012 11:28 pm (UTC)
CLEARLY the merpeople are listening to King Triton.

sweetnessarose 4th-Jul-2012 12:58 am (UTC)
I think it would be fun if mermaids like Ariel did exist, but it's ridiculous that someone had to actually come out and say mermaids aren't real. :|
usagi_moon 4th-Jul-2012 07:26 am (UTC)
yeah, I watched that show, at first I was like "Hmmm could be cool to think about" But then was like "oh ok.......this is really silly"

But yeah Most Cable shows have turned into utter crap now....I just wanna watch cats all day.
antique_faery 4th-Jul-2012 01:44 pm (UTC)
her_historia 4th-Jul-2012 02:10 pm (UTC)
*lalala not listening* ;)
dru_evilista 5th-Jul-2012 04:59 am (UTC)
....lol considering the whole plot of the show was "THEY'RE COVERING UP MERMAIDS EXISTENCE SO PEOPLE DON'T FREAK OUT OVER THEM KILLING MERMAIDS WITH WEAPON TESTING!!!!!!" them going "Mermaids don't exist!" will just make anyone who believed the show flail over the show being proved right.
This page was loaded May 21st 2013, 6:52 am GMT.